Previous Entry | Next Entry

Stranded workers in Doha

  • Jan. 30th, 2007 at 9:51 AM
UNCHR
Two Saturdays ago, my friend Silvia and I visited a labor camp and a safe house here in Doha to learn more about stranded workers in Qatar.

Stranded workers are workers whose sponsors (i.e., employers) have abandoned them in one way or another. For those of us who are expatriate workers in Qatar, our employers have a much larger role in our lives than they would in the States. Your employer isn't just the person who hires you and pays you; they also provide your housing and possibly your food and, most importantly, they are your gateway to government services. When you first arrive in Qatar, it is your sponsor who gets you a valid visa and residency permit; when you leave, it is your sponsor who gets you an exit visa and a plane ticket home. So workers who have been abandoned by their employers are not just unemployed; they also become illegal immigrants. They can't legally get new jobs, and technically shouldn't still be in the country. Yet, even if they want to leave, they can't get an exit visa, let alone afford to fly home!

We met a Nepalese businessman who has devoted himself to helping workers in this situation in Qatar. A few months ago he opened Mitery Kunja, a safe house for stranded workers. Mitery Kunja currently houses about 70 men, mostly Nepalese. Some are there for only a week or two while their embassy sorts out how to get them home; others have been there since it opened in the fall.

Mitery Kunja Safe House Safe House Notice
Mitery Kunja Safe House
Mitery Kunja currently houses 70 stranded workers, but can hold up to 200. Currently it has only two toilets, though.
Safe House Notice
I doubt this sign has much legal standing, but it is an effort to protect the safe house inhabitants from arrest.
Card game Kitchen
Card game
Stranded Nepalese workers keep themselves occupied in the safe house while awaiting the paperwork that will allow them to go home.
Kitchen
Until recently they didn't even have the refrigerator.
Kitchen
Kitchen
Dinner!


Mitery Kunja can help individual workers who get stranded, but unfortunately the problem is larger scale than that. In addition to visiting the safe house, we dropped by a labor camp in the Industrial Area, where hundreds of workers were still living after their sponsor abandoned them. They were brought over on two-year contracts to do Asian-Games-related construction, but two months ago their sponsor stopped paying them, then moved offices, and now is nowhere to be found. Hundreds of workers are still in the labor camp, but with no work, no way of getting food, and now no electricity either.

A soft-spoken 26-year-old man from Burma explained in surprisingly fluent English that the situation was even worse than this. Like many low-skilled workers in Qatar, they never got the deal they had been promised by the agents who recruited them in their home countries. They had been promised a starting salary of 550 riyals ($150) a month, which is typical for construction workers, but with pay raises every few months, first to QR750 and eventually to QR950 ($260). "I did the calculations," he said, "and decided to come." These calculations are carefully considered, because low-skilled laborers typically have to pay agents between $1000 and $2000 to come to Qatar. Their whole extended families go into serious debt to send them over here, on the assumption that two years of salary remittances will pay off the debt and then allow the family to better itself.

When we visited, some of the workers had had an opportunity to transfer to another sponsor. This sponsor would only pay them QR400 ($110) a month, though, and that wasn't enough for them to pay off the debt and provide for their families. When Silvia and I asked the men what they wanted to happen, many were desperate to find work at the promised salary, in order to pay of their debt of coming to Qatar. Others were so entirely fed up with the Gulf they just wanted to go home, even though it meant returning to worse poverty than they were trying to escape by coming here in the first place.

A few days after we visited, the Gulf Times reported that 70 of the workers had gotten a sponsorship change. I hope that means they got a better offer than QR400.

Stranded workers More stranded workers
Stranded workers
More stranded workers


I sat in on Silvia's class (an elective on immigration issues) when she showed the class these pictures and discussed the issue of low-skilled laborers in Qatar. Students had very mixed opinions, but I was a little disappointed by the widespread assumption that these issues are best taken care of by individual embassies. The Nepalese embassy appears to be doing right by its people, but it's hardly fair that they have to spring for plane tickets home for Nepalese workers who are mistreated by Qatari sponsors. The more I learn about the exit visa/plane ticket home situation, the more appalled I am that expatriate workers can be effectively held hostage by their employers. I don't understand how this isn't in violation of international human rights.

In the week since I visited the labor camps, a barrage of other labor-related articles have hit the local papers. Here's a selection.





Comments

( 20 comments — Leave a comment )
(Anonymous) wrote:
Jan. 31st, 2007 05:06 am (UTC)
Lady, i don't know what you're doing on campus - looks like the Doha jounalism scene badly needs you!
[info]qatar wrote:
Feb. 4th, 2007 08:50 am (UTC)
Heh, thanks you!
(Anonymous) wrote:
Mar. 5th, 2007 08:13 pm (UTC)
Laborers
I never got to thank you for the terrific write-up and follow-up to our visit to the labor camp. We just had a wonderful article in the paper last week about a fund-raising dance we planned.

I will be forwarding this link to as many people as possible.

Thanks again, lady! Oh, and by the way, March 30th we're planning a TABLE TOP SALE at the Busy Bees Nursery as another fundraiser. Hope you can join us... e-mail me and I'll send you more details: nanciatcoxdotnet

N-
[info]qatar wrote:
Mar. 12th, 2007 03:34 pm (UTC)
Re: Laborers
Hi Nanci! I'm glad you liked the write-up. I didn't visit the camp with plans to write about it (or I would have cleared it with you first) but I was so convicted by the experience felt I had to share it with people.

I'll be out of town on the 30th, I'm afraid, but keep me informed about other upcoming events, please!
(Anonymous) wrote:
Feb. 23rd, 2009 09:00 am (UTC)
nice effort
information nicely organized. keep it up.
(Anonymous) wrote:
Feb. 5th, 2007 11:56 am (UTC)
interesting
That's a really interesting and saddening fact about low-skilled workers looking to for jobs in another country. In the Philippines it is the same - from domestic helpers in HongKong or in Arab countries, to laborers in Saudi Arabia, these people are lured to another country seeking to better their lives and in turn end up, more often than not, being maltreated, hostaged, duped by employers.

The employment/placement agencies in their home countries play an important role in this issue as well. I've heard of placement agencies back in my country scamming poor families into debt and selling manpower to dubious employers. It's only terrible that these people get stuck because of the exit visa issue. Does this exit visa thing apply to other countries in the Gulf as well?

Am thoroughly enjoying your journal and your insights of life in Qatar. I'm soon going to be relocated there myself, and it's good to have an overview of life in Qatar, not just in terms of tourism but for the deeper issues that matter as well.

-Kala (http://kala.pitas.com)
[info]qatar wrote:
Feb. 26th, 2007 01:24 pm (UTC)
Re: interesting
I was completely appalled by the immigrant laborer situation when I first moved here. After I visited some of the poorer regions of India it started to make more sense. Still, it's a desperate life even for those who AREN'T mistreated.

I'm not sure about the exit visa thing; I know WE need them, but it's possible GCC citizens don't.

Glad you're enjoying the blog!!
(Anonymous) wrote:
May. 9th, 2007 03:45 pm (UTC)
thanks
Dear well wisher,
thanks for your great afford for us , nice to see in your web site story about us, if you need more information regarding MITERY KUNJA ( safe house)please keep in touch.

always with you
gokul kunwar
Founder
Mitery club of qatar and Mitery kunja
Email- miteryclub@gmail.com


[info]qatar wrote:
May. 15th, 2007 09:12 am (UTC)
Re: thanks
Thank you! I'm glad you like the story. I wasn't intending to write one when I visited, or I would have checked with you if it was OK.

Please keep us posted on whether there's anything you need for the safehouse's work to continue.
(Anonymous) wrote:
May. 16th, 2007 10:01 pm (UTC)
Re: thanks
Mitery Up to date news
See how this man come Qatar and Living in our Mitery Kunja ( Safe House )



Name: Jay Bahadur Thapa
Address: Kalika V.D.C. Kanchanpur District, Mahakali Zone, Nepal
Date of Birth: 23/02/1979
Father’s Name: Krishna Bahadur Thapa

My father made two marriages. I am the youngest son from the first marriage. My four elder sisters are all married and live in different part of Nepal. Since long our father has stopped contributing his duty towards his first marriage. We grew up with the support of our mother. At present, I and my family of four live with my mother. My mother, two of my sons, my wife, we all live in a two storey house made of wood and tiled roof. It is in the distance of 10 minutes from the main road. In my mother’s possession, we’ve a piece of land. We grow maize, rice, lentils as per the season.

In absence of my unsupportive and drunkard father, we grew up in a very miserable life. There used to be shortage of food and clothing in the house. My mother was unable to afford our fees in the school and as a result we didn’t get chance to study above than the primary level.

At present, my two sons are studying is Nursery and Kindergarten classes. For their better future, I saw no other ways to earn money rather than going overseas. Being the only breadwinner, I decided what it seems best at that exact time to support my family. I don’t want my children to receive the same hindrance while growing up like I did. I don’t want them to be growing up in shortage of food at home and shield up from education like me and my sister had to endure.

Who can say what will happen the next moment? In great urgency of leaving my country, I loaned 80,000 Nepali Rupees, in 5% interest. I used the money that was saved for the sudden family crisis. In great hope of getting what I had planned, I submitted 70,000 Nepali Rupees to Sam International Manpower for the job of cleaner in Qatar.

In Qatar, I didn’t get the job that I was to do and as was told by the Manpower Company in Nepal. Instead I had to work as a Labour in Al Sakia Building Construction Company as long as 10 months. During the employment period, my medical was done after three months from the joining date. I received 2 months salary but 7 months salary was never paid to me. The company collapsed taking my passport and visa copy with it. Until now, we’ve no clue whether we’ll get back our unpaid salary and the passport.

Its been six months now, since the company left us bewildered in the middle of nowhere, we- the Nepal nationalities, ex- employee of Al Sakia company are staying in a shelter, “ Mitery Kunja”, provided by the Mitery Club of Doha Qatar. We were referred to the Kunja by Acting Ambassador of that time, Mr. Rajendra Pandey of Nepal Embassy. Mitery Kunja has been providing free lodging and fooding as well as accessories needed for daily life. I forward my humble gratitude to the Club and the Kunja Management for helping us to overcome our sorrows, when we are left helpless and distressed in this foreign country.

Speaking of my further interest, I prefer staying here in Qatar, if provided legality. I would better pay back my debts and return home with some money for my family. Otherwise, I hope to receive my pending salary that is remained with the company and also the money that I payed to the manpower of Nepal. I had not loaned and payed the money to buy misery and misfortune for my family and myself. I will try for another country with that money, as remain there as long as I will be able to pay back my dues and lift my family financial status.

Further More information About Mitery kunja and People with us
Email Us we will give you detail
Always with you
Founder
Mitery Club of Qatar
Email. miteryclub@gmail.com
(Anonymous) wrote:
Aug. 31st, 2007 03:28 pm (UTC)
Good work!
I lived in the Gulf for 5 years and was ashamed at what I saw there. It really is modern slavery.

Abdul
(Anonymous) wrote:
Sep. 16th, 2007 04:40 pm (UTC)
Marjorie,
Found your story very interesting. I have just started working for a newspaper out here, and would be very grateful if you could possibly give me any more information regarding the plight of people in similar situations.
If there is any way in which I could communicate with you privately, that would be brilliant. Obviously if you don't wish to speak to me then I understand, but if you do, then lets take it from there. This kind of thing is simply disgusting and if anything can be done to help these poor people then surely it can only be good.
Thank you and keep up the good work
P
[info]qatar wrote:
Sep. 16th, 2007 04:43 pm (UTC)
P,
I would be very happy to talk to you. You can email me at qatar@livejournal.com.
(Anonymous) wrote:
Nov. 3rd, 2007 03:15 pm (UTC)
May be not too late

Dear Ms ,

Thanks alot for what you doing with these poor pepole ,i just have some points that i'm not sure if you checked regarding them .

-The labour agents,they are taking alot of money from them to get them here.Why there country don't save them from these inside agents.

_when they are in the GCC country , shouldn't some body from there GOV check in there conditons , contracts befor even they sighn it.

-some of the sponsers are relly bad to there labours ,but when you have some thing written as contract,there is no problem.

Many things are going wrong in this matter.

If you r still intersted in this subject please e-mail me at aziz_qtr_13@yahoo.com .

Thanks
[info]qatar wrote:
Nov. 30th, 2007 09:13 pm (UTC)
Re: May be not too late
Aziz,

You bring up some good points.

I agree that home-country labor agents are a huge problem. I wish the Nepalese and Indian governments would do more to save workers from them. But, think about how unstable the government of Nepal is. It can't protect its own people, which is part of why they are coming here for work.

The same thing is true of checking workers' conditions. There are 100,000 Nepalese workers in Qatar, but the Nepali embassy only has four employees. How could they check up on all of the workers? What's more, isn't it the Qatari government's responsibility to make sure people are not abused in the state of Qatar? If a Mexican worker is mistreated in the U.S., the American government needs to fix the problem, not the Mexican government. Likewise, the Qatari government should protect the rights of all people in Qatar, not just Qataris.

And finally, I agree that if companies followed their written contracts, the situation would be much better. Unfortunately, they don't. All these men photographed above had contracts with their sponsors, and the sponsors broke those contracts. So, what should happen next for them?
(Anonymous) wrote:
May. 8th, 2008 01:26 pm (UTC)
can u get me a visa?
can u please get me a visiting visa to daha.
or can you link me with a reliable agent in doha for visa proccessing.
you can contact me on :eastgatepetroleum@yahoo.com
[info]qatar wrote:
May. 10th, 2008 09:28 am (UTC)
Re: can u get me a visa?
Sorry, no. I'd recommend you contact the Qatari embassy in your country, which can give you the necessary paperwork.
(Anonymous) wrote:
Oct. 25th, 2008 08:23 am (UTC)
Sad But True...
Hey Lady ... did ya know what happened to the stranded workers whom you cared so much??? Did all your efforts in helping those stranded people work in actuall? Well loads of questions. Sad but true... only the founder got benefitted from your efforts.


Apprecited your effort in helping Nepalese and thank you for your concern... but please make sure the actual people get benefitted.

(Anonymous) wrote:
Jan. 13th, 2009 03:15 pm (UTC)
Do you want any donations? Willing to help!
I currently attend the American School of Doha, and we have multiple clubs and classes that are out to try and help people less fortunate then us. We are lending a helping hand to people in Nepal all the way over to Ethiopia, and we were wondering if you wanted any help to pay for some of the stranded laborers basic essentials, such as food. There are always some kind of food or clothing donation boxes scattered throughout our school, and they get filled fast. If you need any kind of assistance, let me know!
(Anonymous) wrote:
Feb. 20th, 2009 10:46 pm (UTC)
Many thanks for showing what's going on in the real world
I admire your courage and energy in analysing such situations that remind us about cruelty happening behind curtains and waking us up from the soft life that some of us are living
( 20 comments — Leave a comment )